Cheeseburgers are a classic comfort food. Whether you like to add toppings or keep it simple--get ready to sink your teeth into our picks for the juiciest and most unique burgers in the Valley.
551 West | 551 W King St, Lancaster, PA 17603 | @551west
If you can handle the heat you’ll definitely want to try the Jalapeno Burger at 551 West. Jalapeno peppers, pepper jack cheese, and buffalo mayonnaise bring the spice in this Fun burger.
Brickyard Tavern | 748 S Albemarle St, York, PA 17403 | @BrickyardTavern
Get ready to enjoy Brickyard Tavern’s classic Cheeseburger. Oozing in cheese and flavor, this cheeseburger is a fan favorite. Need a side? We’ve heard the steak fries are amazing too.
Burger Yum | 400 N 2nd St, Harrisburg, PA 17101 | @burgeryumharrisburg
Looking for a way to enjoy a cheeseburger, but as a vegetarian? Try Burger Yum’s VeggieYum burger! Made with portobello mushrooms and plenty of cheese, you’ll definitely be able to satisfy your burger craving!
Food 101 | 101 Chambersburg St, Gettysburg, PA 17325 | @food101
Doing meatless Mondays? Food 101 Restaurant has got you covered with their Tuna Burger. Seared rare Mahi, romaine, dijon mustard, and more complete this unique take on a classic.
Gin Mill | 324 E Cumberland St, Lebanon, PA 17042 | @lebanonginmill
Beer and a burger? There’s nothing better! Enjoy a cold craft beer and Gin Mill’s Sweetfire Burger which is stacked with lettuce, tomatoes, bacon, onion rings, and more!
Harvey’s Main Street BBQ | 304 E Main St, Mount Joy, PA 17552 | @harveysbbq
Harvey’s is known for its yummy bbq dishes, but did you know their burgers are equally as good? Try a taste of Louisiana with their Cajun Burger that’s topped with Cajun sausage and spicy BBQ sauce.
The Jackson House | 1004 N 6th St, Harrisburg, PA 17102| @JacksonHouse
Famously known for their burgers, The Jackson House, can consider themselves experts in making the perfect cheeseburger. Don’t forget to order their fries seasoned with sea salt!
Lancaster Dip Co. | 33 - 35 N Market St, Lancaster, PA 17603 | @lancasterdispensingcompany
Are you team bleu cheese or ranch? If you’re all for bleu cheese, Lancaster Dip Co has got you covered! Their Bleu Cheese Burger features melted yummy goodness that will satisfy your tastebuds.
The Lucky Penny Burger Co | @luckypennyburgerco
The Lucky Penny Burger Co food truck themes their burgers in a historic fashion. From the ‘Honest Abe’ (a totally customizable burger) to the ‘Gettysburger’--follow their social media accounts to catch them on location.
Max’s Eatery | 38 W King St, Lancaster, PA | @maxseatey
Max’s eatery is known for its twist on American fare. Their Smash Burger is perfectly cooked on a Alfred & Sam’s roll. Thirsty? Pair it with a boozy milkshake for added fun!
The Midtown Tavern | 1101 N 2nd St, Harrisburg, PA 17102 | @themidtowntavern
A burger for breakfast? How about yes! The Midtown Tavern has a Brunch Burger that combines everything yummy about breakfast like toast and eggs while still sticking to the classic burger.
Official BBQ Burgers | 6295 Lyters Ln, Harrisburg, PA 17111 | @officialbbqandburgers
Pair your Angus Burger with tender barbecue baby back ribs at Official BBQ and Burgers. While you’re there, check out one of their craft beers on tap.
Quentin Tavern | 81 W Main St, Quentin, PA 17083 | @quentintavernrestaurant
Quentin Tavern features a cheeseburger that is a meat lovers dream! Their Reuburger combines your average patty with hot corned beef for a burst of flavor. For some crunch, order a side of chips!
Red Rabbit Drive In | 60 Benvenue Rd, Duncannon, PA 17020 | @redrabbitdrivein
Get a blast of the past at Red Rabbit Drive In. They’re mainly known for being home of the Bunny Burger, which is made up of melted cheese, smoked bacon, a secret special sauce, and more!
Rookie’s Craft Burger Bar | 2238 Derry St, Harrisburg, PA 17104| @rookiescraftburger
If you have a hearty appetite, Rookie’s Double Dribble burger puts you to the test! Challenge yourself to finish two half pound patties topped with plenty of cheese and bacon.
Route 66 Restaurant | 45 W Liberty St #2700, Lancaster, PA 17603 | @thisisroute66
Fans rave about how mouth-watering and juicy the cheeseburgers from Route 66 Restaurant are. An order of waffle fries or steak fries serve as perfect complements to a complete meal.
The SteakOut Food Truck | 917 E Market St, York, PA 17403 | @TheSteakOutYork
Who said a cheeseburger can’t be turned into a hoagie? At the Steak Out, you can have your choice of a regular cheeseburger or have fun by switching it to a hoagie.
